chart comparison

Organic Pest Control Comparison Charts

Charts comparing organic-approved repellents and insecticides by pest, with options preferred in our trials.
By Hensley’s Seed Co.
applying an insect barrier called Surround to seedlings

Organic Pest Control Comparison Charts

Compare repellents and insecticides allowed in organic production. Certified organic growers should confirm with their certifier that a given product is acceptable before using it. Go to:



Repellents recommended for each pest
key Key Top pick= preferred pick of the Hensley's team
Pest Bird Netting Reflective bird-scare tape Plantskydd® Surround® WP Terror-Eyes Balloon Floating row cover
Aphids ✔
Armyworms ✔
Asparagus Beetles ✔ ✔
Birds Top pick ✔ ✔ ✔
Cabbage Loopers ✔
Cabbageworms ✔
Colorado Potato Beetles Top pick
Corn earworm ✔
Corn borer ✔
Cucumber Beetles Top pick Top pick
Deer ✔
Flea Beetles ✔ Top pick
Groundhogs ✔
Spongy moth (gypsy moth) caterpillars ✔
Japanese Beetles ✔ ✔
Leafhoppers ✔ ✔
Mites
Rabbits Top pick ✔
Spider mites
Squash Bugs Top pick ✔
Squash vine borer ✔
Tent Caterpillars ✔
Thrips ✔ ✔
Tomato fruitworm ✔
Tomato Hornworms ✔
Voles ✔
Whiteflies ✔


Organic insecticides recommended for each pest
key Key Top pick= preferred pick of the Hensley's team
Pest AzaGuard® DiPel® DF Monterey Garden
Insect Spray
Pyganic® Sluggo®
Aphids Top pick ✔
Armyworms ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔
Asparagus Beetles ✔ ✔
Cabbage Loopers ✔ Top pick ✔ ✔
Cabbageworms ✔ Top pick ✔ ✔
Colorado Potato Beetles ✔ ✔ ✔
Corn earworm ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔
Corn borer ✔ ✔
Cucumber Beetles ✔ ✔
Cutworms ✔ Top pick ✔
Flea Beetles ✔ ✔ ✔
Japanese Beetles ✔ ✔
Leafhoppers ✔ ✔
Mealybugs ✔ ✔
Mites Top pick ✔
Slugs & snails Top pick
Spotted-wing drosophila (SWD) ✔
Squash Bugs ✔
Squash vine borer ✔
Stink Bugs ✔ ✔
Tarnished plant bug ✔
Thrips Top pick ✔ ✔
Tomato fruitworm ✔ Top pick ✔ ✔
Tomato hornworms ✔ Top pick ✔ ✔
Whiteflies ✔ ✔


Further reading


Source and attribution

Migrated library resource. Original named people, organizations, research, and factual provenance are retained.